GimbalGuru.com
360 Camera Reviews

Best entry-level 360 camera: 2017 Samsung Gear 360 in-depth review with sample 360 videos and photos (Updated July 2, 2018)

Samsung Gear 360 2017 (2018 update)
Samsung Gear 360 2017 (2018 update)

The Samsung Gear 360 2017 received a major update in May of 2018, turning it into a stabilized 360 camera — in fact, the most affordable stabilized 360 camera in the market.  Find out why this made the Gear 360 perfect as a personal camera.   In this hands-on review, I will cover these and other topics:

– Why the Samsung Gear 360 2017 is perfect as a personal camera
– How it will enable you to PERFECT SELFIES the first time, every time
– Gear 360 unboxing: what’s inside
– How to use the Samsung Gear 360 2017 from SHOOTING to SHARING
– Where you can share your photos and videos for more views (besides YouTube and Facebook)
– Gear 360 2017’s advantages and disadvantages
– Its UNIQUE features that no other 360 camera has.
– How to improve image quality with HDR mode: a comparison
– The new dedicated remote: how to pair and why to use it; maximum range.
– The waterproof case
– Samsung Gear 360 2017 compatibility and workarounds
– Facebook’s future plans and why you need to use this camera NOW

I also have sample 360 photos and 360 videos.

Video review

Background: the best value 360 camera

The 2017 Samsung Gear 360 was one of the most highly anticipated 360 cameras for 2017.  The original Samsung Gear 360 was a very good camera (reviewed here) but it had too many requirements, which limited the number of possible users.  Rumors of its successor had been circulating since September 2016 and it was finally revealed at Samsung Unpacked 2017.

The changes in the 2017 Gear 360 addressed nearly all of the concerns about the original Gear 360, including compatibility with non-Samsung phones.  Photo resolution decreased to half of the original (15mp) but the original price also dropped from $350 to $250, hinting that Samsung wanted to appeal to a broader market.

Beginning in the second half of 2017, Samsung began decreasing the price of the Gear 360.  As of July 2018, the price is now under $100, making it one of the best value 360 cameras on the market.

I’ve had the Gear 360 2017 since April 2017, and here is an in-depth review.

How to use the Samsung Gear 360 2017

The 2017 Gear 360 is small and although some have chuckled at its design, there’s no question that it is ergonomically superior to the original Gear 360.  Notwithstanding the difference in appearance, the controls and the look and feel will feel immediately familiar to users of the original Gear 360 – it feels solid and sleek, and the on-camera controls (buttons, OLED screen, menus) are still the best in the industry.

As with the original, you tap the menu button to launch the on-camera menu, then navigate with the menu button to switch options, shutter button for OK/enter, and the power button to go back.

The 2017 Gear 360 connects easily with the app. Launch the app, turn on the camera, and tap on “Connect” and within a few seconds, the app connects to the Gear 360.  (If you’re already connected to your original Gear 360, it will probably try to connect to your old Gear 360 so instead, you tap on the upper right corner and choose the option to connect to a new Gear 360.)

The app’s menus are similar to those of the original.  Here’s the screen with the white balance options shown.

There is a live preview with a pretty good framerate and little lag.  One of the differences from the old app is that there are several viewing modes available:
Here are the available shooting modes:

Landscape HDR is a true multi-shot HDR. It appears to take two shots and blends the exposure.

Here are the available settings.  You can also change exposure compensation (up to 3EV) and there are white balance presets.   For the auto ISO limit, you can choose between 400, 800, or 1600.  Unfortunately, no manual controls.

Shooting is just as easy as it was on the original Gear 360.  Stitching is via the phone.  When you save photos onto your phone, they are stitched at the same time.  One difference is that videos can now be stitched in full resolution on my phone.  With the original Gear 360, you needed an S7 to stitch in 4k, and with a lower-end phone like my S6, phone stitching is limited to 2k.  I haven’t tried stitching on the old Action Director yet.

Live Stream

The Gear 360 2017 is also capable of live streaming.  Here is a sample at 1080p.  Please note that in 2018, the streaming resolution increased to 2560 x 1280.

Compatibility; workarounds for incompatible phones and desktops

The Gear 360 2017 works only with Samsung S6 and above, or iPhone SE and above (iPhone 6 is listed as compatible but the app keeps crashing for 360 videos).

The Gear 360 2017 does include a desktop app for both Windows and Mac, but it will require a 3rd generation Intel Core processor.  The software can be activated with your camera’s serial number.

If your phone and desktop are both incompatible, here are alternatives / workarounds:

1. For stitching photos, you can use the Google Street View app to take photos.  To pair your phone with the Street View app, hold down the menu button on the camera and then press the menu button until you see “Connect to Street View.”  Connect your phone’s Wi-Fi to the Gear 360 using the password shown on the camera’s OLED display.  Once connected, launch the Street View app, click on the camera and select “Link 360 camera.”  Once linked, you can use the Street View app to press the shutter and the photos will be automatically stitched and sent to your phone gallery (in the “360 panorama” album).  You DON’T have to upload them to Google Maps.

Another option for stitching Gear 360 photos is to use nadirpatch.com, a free / ad-driven website.

2. For stitching videos, you can use third-party stitchers.  For Windows, you can use Magix Movie Edit Pro Plus 2018 or later (regular version; discounted student / teacher version).  For Mac, you can use Muvee stitcher.

Workflow; how to share your photos and videos; how to get more views

Photos and videos from the Gear 360 must be ‘stitched’ or combined to make them viewable in 360.  Fortunately, it’s very simple to stitch them.  All you have to do is connect your Gear 360 smartphone app to the camera and save the files to your phone. Saving them to your phone will stitch the files at the same time.

There is also an option in the gallery where you can turn on “Stabilization.”  This will stabilize and stitch the files at the same time.  Otherwise, you will have to stabilize a file after downloading it by tapping on the stabilization button.

It is also possible to stitch the photos and videos in the included desktop software for Windows or Mac. However, the stabilization is nowhere as good as that of the stabilization when stitched in the phone.

After you’ve downloaded your photos and videos to your phone, you can share your photos and videos directly from the app.  Alternatively, you can download them to your desktop and upload them to your preferred social media service.   To get more views, here are some places where you can share your 360 photos and videos (besides YouTube and Facebook):

—- Google Street View (for photos)
—- Google Photos (both photos and videos)
—- Veer (both photos and videos)
—- Kuula (for photos)

Image quality; sample photos and videos

Here are some sample 360 photos and 360 videos and an analysis of their image quality.

Sample 360 photos and videos

Here is a sample 360 video with stabilization:

Here are some sample photos, including some Landscape HDR samples.

Image quality analysis

Resolution and detail: The Gear 360 2017 has very good resolution, with very consistent sharpness across the frame.

Exposure and color: I like the exposure, the colors, the tonality are all excellent in my opinion – well-balanced, natural-looking yet also vibrant and neither dull nor over-processed.  They look good without editing, in my opinion.

Stitching quality: For photos, the stitching quality is excellent except for near objects.  For videos, the stitching will have noticeable warping whenever an object crosses the stitch line near the camera but is otherwise unobtrusive.

Dynamic range:  The Gear 360 2017 has good detail in highlights but not much detail in shadows.  However, both photos and videos have an HDR option.  It’s not a true multi-exposure HDR fusion, but it really does make a difference.  There’s a noticeable improvement in both highlight detail and shadow detail:

HDR option makes a difference for both photos and videos: HDR (left) vs non-HDR (right)
HDR option makes a difference for both photos and videos: HDR (left) vs non-HDR (right)

Chromatic aberration: The Gear 360 2017 has less chromatic aberration than average.  Although it is not totally immune from chromatic aberration, it shouldn’t be an issue for typical situations.

Glare: The Gear 360 2017’s biggest weakness for image quality is its susceptibility to glare.  It has less glare than the original Gear 360, but it is still more vulnerable to glare than many other 360 cameras.

Conclusion: should you buy the Gear 360 2017 in 2018?

In summary, the 2017 Samsung Gear 360 is not only an affordable 360 camera, but with image stabilization and in-camera HDR, offers good quality 360 photos and videos regardless of the price.  Its most significant drawback for image quality is its susceptibility to glare.   However, given the huge price difference from other competing 360 cameras, its shortcomings as to image quality can be overlooked.

The real “catch” to the Gear 360 is that it has limited compatibility and it has a slow workflow.  The new stabilization feature works only in the smartphone app (not the desktop software), and the app in turn only works on Samsung phones (S6 and above) and iPhone SE and above.  Moreover, downloading the photos and videos to your phone to stitch and stabilize them takes a very long time, and the app can crash from time to time, even with a relatively high-end phone such as a Samsung S8+.

If you have a compatible phone, the Gear 360 2017 is probably the best value entry-level 360 camera (available here).  But if you foresee taking many 360 photos or videos, you may want to consider a 360 camera with an easier workflow such as the Xiaomi Mi Sphere (reviewed here) or the Insta360 ONE (reviewed here).

About the author

Mic Ty

7 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • Thanks for posting the photos. I’ve been wondering. I am REALLY looking forward to the Mega 360 Comparision, hopefully with a table. Could you include a column for which have HDR capability built in (you can do HDR with the Nikon but it’s way too much trouble to even bother) as well as one for Live 360 streaming to YT, FB, Periscope, Skype and the rest?

  • Good site I plan on reading every page. But may I make a request? Place some raw, unprocessed video files some place. Just drag some random footage off an SD card. This would allow someone who does not already own a camera to see if their computer cam actually process the footage. Perhaps (as in my case) that have an older Mac

  • Sure app crashes from time to time on my S9. But there is a solution!! You can put SD card into your phone, copy original files to DCIM/Gear 360/ then launch the 360 manager and you will have no one issue during stitching. By the way it is really faster than on PC with AD software.

    P. S. I found that 2016 model has better photo resolution and less noise. Replaceable battery. Most of users prefer this version instead of 2017. But I had an issue, one lens got blurred image, and Samsung replace my camera to new one.